MEDIA
RELEASE 25 July 2006 PULP
MILL INTEGRATED IMPACT STATEMENT DOES NOT PROTECT SEALS FROM PULP MILL POLLUTION
Download a PDF version of this media release. A
major concern about the effluent from Gunns proposed pulp mill is that it will
release persistent organochlorine compounds, including dioxins, into Bass Strait.
These highly toxic pollutants may contaminate fish and animals that feed on them
such as like seals and dolphins. Contaminated
fish may even lead to the accumulation of dioxins in people, a health problem
recently highlighted in a story on Sydney commercial fishermen and their families
on ABC's 7:30 Report1,2. The
Gunns Integrated Impact Statement devotes an entire section to the impact of dioxins
on the seals at the Tenth Island near the effluent outfall3. This section states
on more than one occasion that "dioxins are not significantly bioaccumulated or
biomagnified by fish or bivalves". In
a review of relevant scientific literature, dioxins and other organochlorines
are reported to bioaccumulated in fish and the marine mammals that eat them. The
Government report4 that is a major reference cited in the Gunns IIS clearly states
this, and it is difficult to understand why this information was not repeated
in the Gunns IIS. According
to the Monitoring Plan6, a monitoring program that may identify pollution by chlorine
compounds, including persistent organic pollutants (such as dioxins) is apparently
going "... to be determined in consultation with DPIWE (sic)". A
complete IIS should have this important monitoring program developed to the point
where it can be properly assessed. Dioxins
cause a wide spectrum of adverse toxic effects in many vertebrate species. They
are particularly potent developmental toxicants at low concentrations and can
disrupt the development of the endocrine, reproductive, immune and nervous system
of the offspring of fish, birds and mammals when exposed from conception through
postnatal or post hatching stages. Reported adverse responses include: acute lethality,
reproductive impairment, developmental abnormalities in young, endocrine and immune
dysfunction, neurological dysfunction, wasting syndrome, edema and hemorrhaging3.
The
World Health Organisation states that "long-term, low-level exposure of humans
to dioxins and furans may lead to the impairment of the immune system, the impairment
of the development of the nervous system, the endocrine system and the reproductive
functions. Short-term, high-level exposure may result in skin lesions and altered
liver function. Exposure of animals to dioxins has resulted in several types of
cancer (5)." While
the Tasmanian Government seems highly enthusiastic about building a pulp mill
that will be a source of pollution that will threaten marine mammals, the Minister
for the Environment and Heritage, Senator Ian Campbell, is keen to protect them.
Yesterday (24/7/06), Senator Campbell announced a new Australian Centre for Applied
Marine Mammal Science in Hobart at a cost of $2.5 million. This facility aims
to boost the conservation of our marine mammals. It is hard to see how the Commonwealth
Government can aim to protect Australia's marine mammals on the one hand, while
potentially permitting the dumping of toxic pulp mill effluent into Commonwealth
waters on the other. The
Tasmanian Government could reassure the public about this important issue if it
would announce the introduction of legislation that would stop mill operations
if problems were identified. Further
information: Jon Bryan Phone: (03) 63265684 jonbryan@southcom.com.au
References
1. ABC's 7:30 Report Thursday 20 July 2006. 2. ABC website (24/7/06):
file:///c:/Documents%20and%20Settings/Jon%20Bryan/Desktop/gunns/ abc%20730%20report/s1691649.htm.
3. Comment on Bell Bay Effluent and Potential Impact on Nearby Seal Colonies
Report V10_A23.pdf available from the Gunns website: http://www.gunnspulpmill.com.au/IIS/default.htm
4. Gatehouse R. 2004 National Dioxins Program, Technical Report No. 11 Ecological
Risk Assessment of Dioxins in Australia, Australian Government Report, Department
of the Environment and Heritage (http://www.deh.gov.au/settlements/publications/chemicals/ dioxins/report-11/index.html#download)
5. World Health Organisation website (21/7/06): (http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs281/en/index.html)
6. Monitoring Plan Report V4_part4.pdf available from the Gunns website: http://www.gunnspulpmill.com.au/IIS/default.htm
Download
a PDF version of this media release. |